Best Rubber Straps for Tudor Black Bay 58

The sun’s out, your Tudor Black Bay 58 is on your wrist, and there’s only one thing left to sort before your summer holiday really begins: the strap. Whether you’re heading for the pool, exploring a new city, or just making the most of yet another British heatwave, rubber straps are the ultimate warm-weather upgrade. Comfortable, water-resistant, and full of personality, they let your Tudor go everywhere you do — without breaking a sweat.

And when it comes to versatile watches, the Tudor Black Bay 58 is a certified strap monster. Its vintage-inspired proportions and classic design mean it plays well with all kinds of rubber styles — from sleek tropic textures to bold, modern vented designs. One of our picks is even tailor-made just for the Black Bay 58, offering a flawless fit that looks and feels like it was always meant to be there.

If you’re thinking beyond rubber, you’ll also find plenty of leather and nylon options in our Tudor strap collection — specially curated to suit everything from the Black Bay Pro to the Pelagos FXD.

But for now, let’s dive into our best rubber straps for the Tudor Black Bay 58 — the ultimate summer pairing.

If you want a strap that feels like a factory fit, this is it. Designed specifically for the Tudor Black Bay 58, this WatchGecko Premium Rubber Watch Strap offers a seamless integration with the case thanks to its custom curved ends. That tailored silhouette gives it a high-end look straight out of the box, while the supple rubber keeps things comfortable and secure no matter how active your day gets. It’s an ideal option if you're looking to preserve the Black Bay 58’s sleek aesthetic while still enjoying the practical benefits of a full rubber setup — perfect for poolside lounging, beach days, or just staying cool and collected in the heat.

For those who want the ruggedness of a tool watch with a little extra texture and tactility, the Atlas Sailcloth strap is a smart summer switch. It blends the durability and water resistance of a rubber-lined strap with the tactile finish of sailcloth-style material on top. The result is something that feels casual but elevated — tough enough for a hike or dip in the sea, but still refined enough for dinners on the terrace. On the Black Bay 58, the Atlas brings out the watch’s adventurous character without overcomplicating the clean vintage lines that make it such a strap monster to begin with.

If you like your straps to offer both form and function, the Sedona CTS ticks every box. This cut-to-size rubber strap is built for maximum comfort and precision, featuring a deployant clasp with micro-adjustment capabilities so you can dial in the perfect fit — no matter how much your wrist expands in the sun. It's a real ‘set it and forget it’ option that feels as good at the end of a long day as it does when you first put it on. And if you like the concept but want something with a little more visual flair, check out the Mosaic — it uses the same ultra-functional design, but adds a tile-like pattern that’s perfect for summer wear.

Our Vintage Perforated Rubber Strap brings a sporty retro charm to the Black Bay 58 that feels effortlessly cool. Inspired by classic driving gloves and 60s racing straps, the perforated design isn’t just for looks — it also improves breathability, making it a great choice for hotter days. On the wrist, it gives the Black Bay 58 a slightly more playful edge without veering too far from the tool watch roots. Whether you're wearing it with a linen shirt or a wetsuit, this strap captures that classic summer energy — lightweight, low-maintenance, and full of character.

Channel some proper dive watch heritage with the 285 Italian rubber strap — a timeless design that pairs effortlessly with the Black Bay 58’s vintage diver DNA. With its clean lines, square tail, and supple texture, this strap nails that ‘modern retro’ balance that makes the BB58 so appealing in the first place. It’s soft and flexible for long wear, while the vented pattern adds a bit of visual interest without being too shouty. Whether you’re actually diving or just dreaming about it, this strap helps your Black Bay feel ready for anything.

From tailored rubber to retro racing vibes, these straps show just how versatile the Tudor Black Bay 58 can be when it comes to warm-weather style. Each one brings out a different side of this modern classic — whether you're looking for maximum comfort, everyday durability, or a strap that makes a subtle summer statement. Explore these options and more in our full Tudor strap collection, where you’ll find the perfect pairing for any Tudor — and any summer adventure.